PLANETARY OCCULTATIONS GROUP
Lunar & Planetary Laboratory
University of Arizona
Tucson, Arizona 85721
(NOTE! - This is arranged by date with the first postings appearing first.
For the latest information go to the end of this page. For earlier and
possibly outdated information on this event go here)
(The following is condensed from email of Bruno Sicardy and David Dunham
acting on mail they received from Claudio Martinez in Argentina who
first identified this event.)
The occultation will take place on Sept. 8, 2001, and the most favourable
region of visibility will be South America (Ecuador, Peru, etc...). The
event could also be visible low above the horizon from Southern France
and Spain. A GIF file of the currently predicted path is reproduced below.
The star is very bright (V= 7.2, and even brighter in the IR), vs. 13.9
for Titania, so that the contrast will be very good. It is an Hipparcos
star (#106829), so that predictions should be good too. But the prediction
could change somewhat as we approach the time of occultation.
One goal of this observing effort would be to detect an atmosphere of this
satellite. It is 800 km in radius, bigger than Charon, and 60% the size of
Triton. On the other hand, it is quite warmer: ~ 60 K from IR observations
(Grundy et al, Icarus 142, 536, 1999).
This is a very rare and bright event, and we should not miss a good opportunity
to make some science with it.
As you can see from the attached map, Colombia, Venezuela, Iberia, and France
are all within the predicted path for this occultation by Titania, the
largest satellite of Uranus. It will occur on 2001 Sept. 8 U.T. at about
2h U.T., or the evening of Sept. 7 local time in South America. Using a
diameter of 1580 km = 0.114" for Titania, a central occultation would last
76 seconds with a 6.4-mag. drop. The star can be located with the help
of finder charts for Uranus; it is at J2000 RA 21h 38m 14.0s, Dec -14 deg.
54' 36".
Original occultation path plot from David Herald, 3/01.
Go here for the latest, updated plot!
Here is further information on the star:
Aliases:
HD 205829 BD-15 6027 GC 30276
GSC 05799-01022 HIC 106829 HIP 106829
IRAS 21354-1508 PMC 90-93 6284 PPM 239128
SAO 164538 SKY# 41252 SRS 16903
TYC 5799 1022 1 uvby98 100205829 YZ 105 8137
ZC 3167
ICRS 2000.0 coordinates 21 38 13.9595 -14 54 35.958 [11.30 6.30 94]
FK5 2000.0/2000.0 coordinates 21 38 13.96 -14 54 36.0 [11.30 6.30 94]
FK4 1950.0/1950.0 coordinates 21 35 29.60 -15 08 10.6 [65.39 36.80 92]
Galactic coordinates: 38.01 -43.58
Proper motion (mas/yr) [error ellipse] 26.77 29.50 [ 1.27 .72 93]
B magn, V magn, Peculiarities 8.24, 7.20
Spectral type: K0III
Parallaxes (mas) 5.89 [.91]
The lightcurves below show computed occultation signatures of static
Titania atmospheres of pure nitrogen with surface pressures of 0.1
(blue) and 1 microbar (black). The atmospheres are assumed to be at a
constant temperature of 60 K. The 1-microbar atmosphere would be
easily detected. The 0.1-microbar atmosphere could be detected with
good photometry (at a level of about +/- 3% for 1-sec integrations).
This could be achieved with a large aperture or by combining a large
number of independent observations. Both approaches are desirable.
If the atmosphere is in a state of blow-off, like a cometary
atmosphere, the atmospheric density might vary proportional to 1/r^2,
much more slowly than an exponential static atmosphere. The
occultation signature of this case would be a much more gradual decline
in flux, as shown in green in the figure below. To be detectable, the
base density of such an atmosphere would have to be at least equal to
the density of a 1-microbar atmosphere at 60 K.
All this assumes an occulted star with a radius about 15 times the
Sun's, with a distance for the given parallax of 170 pc. We now
estimate a projected stellar diameter at Uranus equal to about 11 km,
or 0.54 s in time.
Dear Titanians,
You will find linked to this page three JPEG files showing synthetic
light curves for the Titania occultation, for three hypothetical
pressures at the surface: 15, 1 and 0.1 mubar.
All the curves assume N2 atmosphere with scale height H= 47 km
(corresponding
to T= 60K).
Each figure is supposed to have 4 panels (will be fixed later).
The pressure printed in the lower left corner is the pressure at the
surface.
The quantity "b" is the impact parameter, i.e. the distance of closest
approach of the observer to the center of Titania's shadow.
Remarks:
-------
- Detecting a 15 mubar atmosphere (like Triton) is pretty obvious. Note that a
detection is possible even with b= 1000 km, i.e. more than 200 km OUTSIDE the
geometrical radius of the satellite (790 km). Note that a grazing occultation
(b= 790 km) is pretty obvious.
Hence the importance to observe even if one is outside the predicted
geometrical path.
- A 1 mubar atmosphere is pretty obvious too. Note that grazing occultations
(b= 700-750 km) detect more easily an atmosphere that central ones. This is
because the drop of signal due to the atmosphere last longer and has a shallower
slope for grazing events than for central ones.
Again grazing observers are welcome!
- A 0.1 mubar atmosphere is probably the limit of what we can do. Once again
grazing occultations are more sensitive to an atmosphere than central
events. Note that the drop due to the atmosphere just before the drop due to
the physical limb is about 7%, not much!
- I am thinking about another method to detect a faint atmosphere. Refraction
"shrinks" a little bit the physical shadow of Titania. For p= 0.1 mubar, this
shrinking amounts to about 4 km radially. Thus, even if we cannot see the
faint 7% atmospheric drop, we can at least measure the radius of the
shadow, using the timings at various stations.
The shadow moves at about 20 km s-1, thus we need an sub-second accuracy for
the absolute timing at each station, on order for this method to work. Also, we
need a good sampling for the light curve, since the star is going to smooth the
signal over ~ 0.5 sec anyway.
Best regards
Bruno Sicardy
From: Bruno.Sicardy@obspm.fr Thu Jul 26 10:23:06 2001
Dear Titania observers,
I found in a double star list
(see http://www.mapug.com/AstroDesigns/MAPUG/DbleStar/DbleStar1.htm)
a system which nicely simulate (IN THE VISIBLE) Uranus and Titania
during
the occultation:
SAO 10937 (HIP 207 and 208),
RA: 00h 02m 36.087 sec
DE: +66d 05' 56.28" (J2000)
with separation 15.2 arsec,
V= 5.9, type G8 III,
V= 7.2, type A2 V,
for each star respectively.
It could be useful for tests of saturation, scattered light, scale,
etc...
and easy because it is in Cassiopea.
Note however that the fainter star is rather blue, while the occulted
star is
read (type K0 III) so that the test will be misleading outside the V
band.
Cheers,
Bruno
From Bruno....
Some remarks about the observations in Venezuela:
->The most important is to get a lightcurve of the event with
sufficient time resolution. Titania is going 20 km/sec with respect to
the star, projected onto the the plane of the sky. Thus we need 1sec
resolution or better in order to resolve an atmosphere, which is
likely to have a scale height of no more than 30-40 km.
->Fast CCD images or video, or any fast imager with reasonable
linearity are ok. A fast aperture photometer could be tricky becaus
Uranus will be close and bright (V= 5.7 at 16 arcsec from the star, V=
7.1). Scattered light from the planet would contaminate the aperture,
and make the interpretation of the lightcurve difficult after the
event. The best would be at have some IOTA cameras in Venezuela, or
some good video camera whose signal could be digitized afterward.
->It is important to record the all event, not just the ingress and
egress. If the atmosphere is thick enough, the occultation will be
rather smooth and the star may not disappear completely even when it
is the geometrically behind Titania.
->It is important to note that there is still an uncertainty which
corresponds to about one radius or more of Titania. In other words, the
gray stripe on the diagrams (track of the shadow on the Earth) may still
shift north or south by half its width or even more. So, it would be wise
to observe even if you are outside the nominal track.
->I do not think that spectra will be very useful, since the atmos.
will be so tenuous that absorption lines will be impossible to detect.
->We do NOT know if Titania has an atmosphere. This is a prospective
experiment. The problem is the star scintillation in the Earth atmos,
NOT the photon noise, since the star is so bright. Thus, a big
telescope like the 1-m is good not because it collects more photons,
but because it reduces the scintillation wrt a 20cm telescope. Under
good conditions, we can detect down to 10^{-7} bars at the surface of
the satellite.
->To make tests, you can use a double star which simulates nicely
Uranus + the star at the moment of the occultation:
SAO 10937 (HIP 207 and 208 in Cassiopea, RA: 00h 02m 36.087 sec DE:
+66d 05' 56.28" (J2000)
with separation 15.2 arsec, V= 5.9, type G8 III, V= 7.2, type A2 V,
for each star respectively.
It could be useful for tests of saturation, scattered light, scale,
etc... Note however that the occulted star is red, while the fainter
star in the binary above is blue, so tests could be misleading outside
the V band.
Cheers
Bruno Sicardy
Observatoire de Paris
92195 Meudon
Cedex
Principal France
<+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+><+>
Dear Titanians,
I received last week astrometric results from Bordeaux, giving some
O-C's for the Uranian system. Michel Rapaport obtained 11 positions for
Uranus, 7 for Titania and 7 for Oberon, wrt Hipparcos stars, with the
meridian instrument. The average O-C obtained from Titania and Oberon
positions is:
O-C alpha*cos(delta)= -0.065"
O-C delta = -0.057"
which yields the track shown in the attached ps file.
This new prediction is north of, but otherwise essentially the same as the
one previously derived from Bill Owen's observations at Table Mountain,
and from which I derived the tracks posted on Rik Hill's site on July 20
(see http://www.lpl.arizona.edu/~rhill/planocc/titania/titania.html)
I did not include the O-C of Uranus in the present track, since the planet
is 3.8" across, and thus with a more poorly defined photocenter than
the satellite. In any case the O-C of Uranus would not change much the
present track.
There is still a problem of error bars: the Bordeaux observations have
typical dispersions of < ~ 50 mas, i.e. about one Titania radius. Thus,
the track shown in the attached ps file can still be off by +/- one
Titania radius, i.e. one Titania diameter full width.
In other words, all the observations (Ron Stone, Bill Owen, Michel
Rapaport) are pretty consistent, but none of them really pin down the
error bars below +/- one Titania radius. Averaging all these results is
tricky because some systematic errors could linger in each of these
observations.
What would be needed now is having Titania and the star on the same plate
and make direct differential astrometry. The two bodies are about 1 deg
apart now.
Can anybody do that ????????????
Cheers
Bruno
From: Bruno SICARDY
Subject: Titania astrometry update
Here is a brief account of the latest astrometric measurements of the
Uranian system:
- Bordeaux results (Michel Rapaport):
O-C alpha * cos(delta) = -0.075 arcsec, O-C delta= -0.030 arcsec.
Then the occultation is grazing in southern Portugal, Madeira, and the
shadow cuts in half Ecuador.
Venezuela and Aruba are in full shadow.
- NOFS: O-C= -0.119, -0.079 arcsec in alpha and delta, resp.
Than Portugal, Madeira, Venezuela, aruba and Ecuador and in full shadow.
- Table Mountain: (Bill Owen) O-C= -0.153, -0.034 arcsec. Portugal,
Madeira and Ecuador are outside the shadow. Venezuela and Aruba are
in. This later results is at contrast with all the other previous
measurements, essentially because of a relatively high offset in alpha
(-0.175 arcsec instead of more typical values of -0.070 arcsec).
There is no explanation for this divergent result, according to Bill
Owen.
Thus the shadow is still wandering around with no definite
convergence... Madeira, Southern Portugal and Southern Ecuador are
dangerously close to the southern limit of the shadow. But remember that
grazing occns are best for detecting an atmosphere.
Note that all the astrometric masurements indicate that the occn by
Titania will occur SOONER than predicted by the nominal JPL Titania
ephemeris. It should occur around 1:54-1:55 UT sept. 8 in Europe, and
around 2:00-2:01 UT in S. America. Be prepared! (and correct the diagram
in Sky and Telescope, Sept. issue, p. 95
Created by:
Richard E. Hill.
Please report any problems or suggestions to (rhill@lpl.arizona.edu)